Not indexed isn't a diagnosis
Every so often a statistic does the rounds: some huge share of websites are "losing traffic" to pages Google has stopped indexing. It sounds alarming. It isn't news. A page that isn't in the index can't get traffic. That's what not being indexed means.
The figure also tells you nothing you can act on. It doesn't say which pages, how much traffic or why they dropped out. And "why" is the only question that matters, because each answer has a different fix and some of them don't need fixing at all.
Search Console's Pages report gives you a reason for every URL it hasn't indexed. Here's how to work through them.
1. Did you remove it?
Start with the reasons you caused yourself:
- Not found (404) or a 410
- Excluded by "noindex" tag
- Blocked by robots.txt
- Alternate page with proper canonical tag
For each one, ask whether you meant it. A 404 for a product you no longer sell is fine. Google doesn't penalise a site for having 404s. A noindex left over from staging, a robots.txt rule that's too broad or a canonical pointing at the wrong place is an own goal. This site had eight pages sitting under "Alternate page with proper canonical tag" because every canonical pointed at the wrong host.
Fix: if it was deliberate, leave it. If it wasn't, put it right and request indexing.
2. Did you move it?
Page with redirect isn't a problem in itself. A redirected URL is supposed to drop out of the index, with its traffic moving to the new page.
Check three things:
- It's a 301, not a 302.
- It goes straight to the final page, not through a chain.
- It goes to the closest matching page, not the homepage.
Then check the new page actually picked up the traffic. If the old URL's traffic disappeared and the new page didn't gain it, the redirect points at the wrong place. After a site move this is where most of the damage hides, which is why migration audits start here.
3. Is Google wasting its visits?
Discovered, currently not indexed means Google knows the URL exists but hasn't crawled it yet.
On a large site that's often crawl budget. Google is spending its visits on URLs that don't matter: parameters, filters, faceted navigation, duplicates and redirect chains. Look at what it's crawling instead of your real pages and close those routes off.
On a small site crawl budget is rarely the issue. More often Google hasn't seen enough reason to visit. The page is buried, has few internal links pointing to it or sits in a section that has disappointed before.
Fix: cut the waste and link to the pages you care about from pages Google already visits. Both are part of a technical SEO audit.
4. Is the page worth indexing?
Crawled, currently not indexed means Google read the page and decided not to index it, for now at least.
Look at the page honestly. Is it thin? Does it repeat something better elsewhere on your site? Is it one of fifty near-identical location or tag pages? Duplicate without user-selected canonical and Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user belong here too. Google has decided another page says the same thing.
Fix: improve it, merge it into the stronger page or remove it deliberately. Resubmitting it unchanged won't help.
5. Does it matter?
Only now do you know whether anything was actually lost. Rank what's left by its past traffic and the links pointing at it.
A dropped page with no links and no traffic history may not be worth saving. A dropped page that used to bring in visitors, or that other sites link to, is where the effort goes. If it's gone for good, redirect it to the closest page so the links still count for something.
The work is the diagnosis
None of this fits in a scary percentage. It's a list of URLs, a reason for each one and a decision for each one. It's slower than posting a statistic, but it's the only version that changes anything.
For the mistakes that cause most of the problems in step 1, see Twelve SEO own goals, two of them mine.
