Who do you believe? Facts on a flooded web

We make decisions on facts we never check ourselves. Which product to buy, which company to trust, what's happening in a war we're watching from thousands of miles away. We trust that the places we read those facts got them right. The web has made that trust harder to give and easier to abuse.


The flood

There has never been more information available, and never more claims dressed up as information. A conflict breaks out and within minutes both sides are publishing their versions, along with old footage recirculated as new and images that may not have been taken by a camera at all. A political figure says something, and supporters and opponents have declared it proof of everything they already believed before anyone has checked what was actually said. Donald Trump is the obvious example, but it happens around every polarising figure, on every side.

Then there's the everyday version: the confident statistic in a LinkedIn post, the screenshot of a screenshot, the "study" nobody can find. On their own they're small. Together they're the material the next search result and the next AI answer are built from.

Brevity wins, and that's the problem

The formats that dominate the web reward the short and the certain. A headline, a clip, a post that fits on one screen. A claim can be made in a sentence. Checking it takes a paragraph, and correcting it takes an article most people won't read.

There's an old line for this: a lie travels halfway round the world while the truth is still putting its boots on. It's usually credited to Mark Twain or Winston Churchill. Neither said it. The earliest version is generally traced to Jonathan Swift in 1710, and it took on its modern wording long after him. Even the saying about misinformation has been misattributed for a century, because the famous name is a better story than the true one.

The machines are reading it too

Search engines and AI assistants don't know what's true. They read what's published and weigh it. Repetition and trusted sources count for a lot. So when the web is flooded with confident claims, the machines summarising it can end up repeating the loudest version, fluently and with no sign of doubt.

That changes the question from "who do I believe?" to "who is the machine believing on my behalf?" More and more people never see the sources at all. They see the summary.

How do machines decide what's true?

They don't, not in the way we mean it. A search engine or AI model has no direct line to the world. It learns from what people have written and decides which version to trust using signals: how many independent sources agree, how reliable those sources have been before, who links to and cites them, how recent they are and whether the facts are stated consistently in a form it can read. Google keeps a store of facts about people, places and companies that it checks against sources it trusts. AI assistants increasingly look things up before they answer instead of relying on memory.

All of that is a way of estimating truth from evidence people put there. If we don't know, or the evidence is a mess of contradictions, the machine doesn't know either. It goes with the best-supported version, which isn't always the right one.

That's why the people who publish the web matter, and SEO is a big part of that. Its job is to make accurate information easy to find, easy to read and backed up. But SEO hasn't always dealt in facts. Plenty of it has dealt in volume: thin pages, bought links, inflated statistics and now mass-produced AI content. That's part of the flood. So SEO is vital, but only the honest kind. The industry can make the evidence better or worse, and the machines will learn from whichever it does.

What counts as a fact?

Most of what we read online isn't fact. It's claims, estimates and opinions in the voice of fact. Before I treat anything as fact, I ask a few questions:

None of this takes long. It's the habit of asking before repeating.

Who to believe

There isn't a single source to trust on everything, and anyone who says they're that source should make you more careful, not less. What tends to hold up is evidence over volume, original sources over summaries, people who show their working over people who just show confidence, and outlets that correct their mistakes in public.

For businesses the lesson is the same one at a smaller scale. The facts about you are on the web whether you put them there or not. Make sure the right ones are easy to find, consistent everywhere and backed up by sources other than yourself. When the flood comes, that's what gets repeated. More on why that's the real job of SEO in SEO isn't dead. The acronyms are.

Sources: Quote Investigator on "A lie can travel halfway around the world", PolitiFact on the Churchill misattribution